XX株式会社殿

TR-23-0026

TS01 Automotive Wind Tunnel Test Report


Test Condition

  • Date & Time of Test: 4/14/2023
  • Measured Sample: Automobile 12U
  • Refer to Attached Test Conditions for each RUN no. detail and overview.

RUN No.

  • Data is shown for Run No.: 006~008: Base Configuration with Spoiler deployed. and RUN011~013: Same configuration re-run.
  • Refer to Attached Test Conditions for each RUN no. detail and overview.


Table of Contents



Analysis Options


Data Normalizing

  • [ - ] Normalized with Flow Velocity (Standard 15.0m/s)
  • [ - ] Normalized with Flow Velocity and Density (Standard 1.225 kg/m3)
  • [ N ] Normalizing not used

Options

  • [ Y ] Basic Data Analysis
  • [ - ] Smoke Visualization Option
  • [ - ] Tuft Visualization Option
  • [ - ] High Speed Imaging
  • [ Y ] Data Filtering
  • [ Y ] FFT Analysis
  • [ - ] Discussions

Calculation Definitions

  • No custom functions.

Filter Settings

  • Sampling Rate: 100Hz
  • Low Pass Gauss Filter (LPF) Frequency: 10Hz
  • High Pass Filter (HPF) Frequency: 15Hz

Analysis Result


Definitions

  • DateName: Name of RUN Number
  • Velocity_Ave: Average Wind Speed in [m/s]
  • Pitot_Ave: Average Pitot tube dynamic pressure in [Pa]
  • CdA: Cd x Frontal Area [m2]
  • ClA: Cl x Frontal Area [m2]
  • Drag_N_Ave: Average Drag in [N]
  • LF_N_Ave: Average Frontal Lift in [N]
  • LR_N_Ave: Average Rear Lift in [N]
  • SF_N_Ave: Average Side Force in [N]

  • XXX_stdev: Standard Deviation during each RUN for data XXX

  • XXX_HPF_stdev: Standard Deviation of HPF applied RUN data
  • XXX_HPF_Ave: Average value of HPF applied RUN data. 0 means fully random noise.



Results for RUNs 006-008

Gauss Filtered Averaged Values each RUN: (m/s),(N)

DataName CdA ClA Drag_N_Ave LF_N_Ave LR_N_Ave SF_N_Ave offset_Drag offset_Lift
0 RUN6 0.625 0.107 87.146 21.073 -6.098 -3.295 0.433 -0.055
1 RUN7 0.628 0.102 87.999 21.192 -6.925 -3.232 -0.346 -0.145
2 RUN8 0.623 0.107 87.806 21.960 -6.929 -3.366 -0.884 -0.204

Gauss Dynamic Pressures (Pa)

Pitot_Ave_Ave Velocity_Ave Pitot_1_Ave Pitot_2_Ave Pitot_3_Ave Pitot_4_Ave Pitot_5_Ave Pitot_6_Ave
0 139.597 15.306 142.666 146.671 144.959 137.525 140.536 132.299
1 140.257 15.340 142.825 141.157 146.566 138.662 140.838 132.393
2 140.961 15.379 146.094 137.734 146.989 139.008 142.400 130.310

STD Deviations each RUN LPF:

DataName Pitot_Ave_stdev Velocity_stdev Drag_N_stdev LF_N_stdev LR_N_stdev SF_N_stdev
0 RUN6 2.555 0.141 2.229 1.723 3.624 2.638
1 RUN7 2.339 0.129 2.109 1.872 3.616 2.533
2 RUN8 2.411 0.132 2.063 1.751 3.373 2.598

STD Deviations Random Noise HPF>cutoff freq.:

DataName Pitot_Ave_HPF_stdev Drag_HPF_stdev LF_HPF_stdev LR_HPF_stdev SF_HPF_stdev
0 RUN6 0.079 0.358 0.943 0.940 0.635
1 RUN7 0.078 0.355 0.917 0.920 0.633
2 RUN8 0.076 0.358 0.905 0.926 0.641
DataName Pitot_Ave_HPF_Ave Drag_HPF_Ave LF_HPF_Ave LR_HPF_Ave SF_HPF_Ave
0 RUN6 -0.0 -0.0 -0.0 0.0 0.0
1 RUN7 0.0 -0.0 0.0 -0.0 0.0
2 RUN8 -0.0 0.0 -0.0 0.0 0.0

Summary of RUNs


Average and stdev Summary of all RUNS

Definitions

  • Mass: Vehicle Total Mass [kg]
  • CG_x: Center of gravity in Drag direction. 0=CG at vehicle wheelbase centerline, +is in aft direction. [m]
  • CG_y: Center of gravity in Side direction. 0=CG at vehicle tread centerline. [m]
  • CG_z: Center of gravity height. Cannot be measured by this system.
  • FL_weight: Corner weight value at Front Left Wheel [kg]
  • FR_weight: Corner weight value at Front Right Wheel [kg]
  • RL_weight: Corner weight value at Rear Left Wheel [kg]
  • RR_weight: Corner weight value at Rear Right Wheel [kg]

  • F-R_WtBalance: Front to Rear Weight Balance [-]
  • R-L_WtBalance: Right to Left Weight Balance [-]
  • Velocity_Ave: Average Wind Speed [m/s]
  • Velocity_stdev: Velocity standard deviation [m/s]
  • Air_Density: Average Air Density [kg/m3]
  • L/D: Vehicle Lift to Drag Ratio[N/N]

  • Pitot_Ave_HPF_stdev: Standard Deviation of Pitot tube dynamic pressure HPF applied values [Pa]
  • Pitot_Ave_HPF_Ave: Average of Pitot tube dynamic pressure HPF applied values. 0 means fully random noise [Pa]
  • Drag_N_Ave: Average Drag in [N]
  • Drag_N_stdev: Standard Deviation of Drag in [N]
  • Lift_N_Ave: Average Lift in [N]
  • Lift_N_stdev: Standard Deviation of Lift in [N]
  • SF_N_Ave: Average Side Force in [N]
  • SF_N_stdev: Standard Deviation of Side Force in [N]
  • LF_N, LR_N: Frontal and Read Lifts respectively [N]

  • Cp_x: Center of Pressure in x direction. 0= at vehicle wheelbase centerline, applicable only to downforce generating cars [m]
  • CD_x: Center of Drag in x direction. [m]
  • X_CpCG: Distance between CG (CoG) and Cp_x [m]
  • X_CDCG: Distance between CG (CoG) and CD_x [m]
  • PM: Pitching Moment around vehicle CG_x [Nm]
  • YM: Yawing Moment around vehicle CG_x [Nm]
  • RM: Roll Moment around vehicle CG_x [Nm]

  • Drag_N_Norm: Normalized Drag. Applicable only when Normalize option is specified. [N]
  • Lift_N_Norm: Normalized Lift. Applicable only when Normalize option is specified. [N]



Average and Standard Deviation for all RUNs (Applicable only to Same Wind Speed)

Mass CG_x CG_y FL_Weight FR_Weight RL_Weight RR_Weight
All Runs Average -1399.918 0.168 0.009 -297.287 -307.461 -400.810 -394.359
All RUNs STDEV 0.044 0.000 0.000 0.025 0.025 0.032 0.022

F-R_WtBalance R-L_WtBalance Velocity_Ave Velocity_stdev Air_Density L/D
All Runs Average 0.432 0.501 15.342 0.134 1.192 0.168
All RUNs STDEV 0.000 0.000 0.037 0.006 0.000 0.006
Pitot_Ave_stdev Pitot_Ave_Ave Pitot_Ave_HPF_stdev Pitot_Ave_HPF_Ave Drag_N_Ave Drag_N_stdev
All Runs Average 2.435 140.272 0.078 0.0 87.650 2.134
All RUNs STDEV 0.110 0.682 0.002 0.0 0.447 0.086
Lift_N_Ave Lift_N_stdev SF_N_Ave SF_N_stdev ClA CdA LF_N_Ave LF_N_stdev LR_N_Ave LR_N_stdev
All Runs Average 14.757 4.578 -3.298 2.590 0.105 0.625 21.408 1.782 -6.651 3.538
All RUNs STDEV 0.426 0.078 0.067 0.053 0.003 0.003 0.481 0.079 0.479 0.143
Cp_x CD_x X_CpCG X_CDCG PM YM RM
All Runs Average -17.017 0.308 -17.185 0.140 -6.619 -19.990 -0.990
All RUNs STDEV 25.060 0.007 25.061 0.007 0.919 0.365 0.052
Pitot_1_Ave Pitot_2_Ave Pitot_3_Ave Pitot_4_Ave Pitot_5_Ave Pitot_6_Ave offset_Drag offset_Lift
All Runs Average 143.862 141.854 146.171 138.398 141.258 131.667 -0.266 -0.135
All RUNs STDEV 1.935 4.509 1.071 0.776 1.000 1.176 0.662 0.075

Measured Data Values


FFT Result

Results for RUNs 011-013

Gauss Filtered Averaged Values each RUN: (m/s),(N)

DataName CdA ClA Drag_N_Ave LF_N_Ave LR_N_Ave SF_N_Ave offset_Drag offset_Lift
0 RUN11 0.630 0.101 88.903 21.083 -6.851 -2.696 0.255 -0.098
1 RUN12 0.627 0.097 89.454 21.197 -7.369 -3.188 0.143 0.036
2 RUN13 0.632 0.102 89.474 21.213 -6.768 -3.407 0.278 -0.231

Gauss Dynamic Pressures (Pa)

Pitot_Ave_Ave Velocity_Ave Pitot_1_Ave Pitot_2_Ave Pitot_3_Ave Pitot_4_Ave Pitot_5_Ave Pitot_6_Ave
0 141.108 15.325 144.737 144.481 146.496 137.718 144.007 132.579
1 142.789 15.414 153.908 142.469 148.834 136.697 144.639 129.869
2 141.599 15.351 142.618 140.658 149.155 141.323 142.786 132.114

STD Deviations each RUN LPF:

DataName Pitot_Ave_stdev Velocity_stdev Drag_N_stdev LF_N_stdev LR_N_stdev SF_N_stdev
0 RUN11 2.441 0.132 2.192 1.814 3.545 3.083
1 RUN12 3.432 0.186 2.286 1.726 3.386 2.352
2 RUN13 2.856 0.156 2.096 1.736 3.767 2.589

STD Deviations Random Noise HPF>cutoff freq.:

DataName Pitot_Ave_HPF_stdev Drag_HPF_stdev LF_HPF_stdev LR_HPF_stdev SF_HPF_stdev
0 RUN11 0.083 0.356 0.881 0.907 0.628
1 RUN12 0.080 0.366 0.928 0.956 0.649
2 RUN13 0.078 0.372 0.948 0.944 0.658
DataName Pitot_Ave_HPF_Ave Drag_HPF_Ave LF_HPF_Ave LR_HPF_Ave SF_HPF_Ave
0 RUN11 0.0 0.001 0.0 -0.0 -0.0
1 RUN12 -0.0 -0.001 0.0 -0.0 -0.0
2 RUN13 0.0 0.000 -0.0 -0.0 -0.0

Average and Standard Deviation for all RUNs (Applicable only to Same Wind Speed)

Mass CG_x CG_y FL_Weight FR_Weight RL_Weight RR_Weight
All Runs Average -1400.177 0.168 0.011 -296.674 -308.131 -401.842 -393.530
All RUNs STDEV 0.028 0.000 0.000 0.003 0.004 0.018 0.019

F-R_WtBalance R-L_WtBalance Velocity_Ave Velocity_stdev Air_Density L/D
All Runs Average 0.432 0.501 15.363 0.158 1.202 0.159
All RUNs STDEV 0.000 0.000 0.046 0.027 0.000 0.003
Pitot_Ave_stdev Pitot_Ave_Ave Pitot_Ave_HPF_stdev Pitot_Ave_HPF_Ave Drag_N_Ave Drag_N_stdev
All Runs Average 2.910 141.832 0.080 0.0 89.277 2.191
All RUNs STDEV 0.498 0.864 0.003 0.0 0.324 0.095
Lift_N_Ave Lift_N_stdev SF_N_Ave SF_N_stdev ClA CdA LF_N_Ave LF_N_stdev LR_N_Ave LR_N_stdev
All Runs Average 14.168 4.697 -3.097 2.675 0.100 0.630 21.164 1.759 -6.996 3.566
All RUNs STDEV 0.313 0.219 0.364 0.373 0.003 0.003 0.071 0.048 0.326 0.191
Cp_x CD_x X_CpCG X_CDCG PM YM RM
All Runs Average -0.789 0.286 -0.957 0.118 -7.405 -10.349 -0.777
All RUNs STDEV 3.677 0.017 3.677 0.017 0.323 0.542 0.099
Pitot_1_Ave Pitot_2_Ave Pitot_3_Ave Pitot_4_Ave Pitot_5_Ave Pitot_6_Ave offset_Drag offset_Lift
All Runs Average 147.088 142.536 148.162 138.579 143.811 131.521 0.225 -0.098
All RUNs STDEV 6.001 1.912 1.451 2.430 0.942 1.449 0.072 0.134

Measured Data Values


FFT Result

Conclusion

Discussions

  • Vehicle exhibits hight lift without the use of active rear spoiler. The rear spoiler is essential to maintain stability during high speed.
  • The vehicle has an extremely low drag coefficient which may be further improved by the use of a more efficient rear spoiler.
  • Vehicle natural frequency is at 1.8Hz, 4Hz and 7Hz. Frequencies emerge constantly with good reproductivity. The vibration level is very low with most values under 15N^2/Hz
  • Due to the extreme front toe-out geometry, a gain in side force is obsereved when drag is applied to the vehicle.

Conclusions and Recommendations

  • Increased frontal downforce should be considered by use of a front splitter for improved stability.
  • The rear spoiler is effective is creating a large amount for rear downforce, however has a low L/D coefficient. A larger wing area with laminar flow should be considered for improved drag and rear downforce.
  • Frontal geometry shall be reconsidered. The extreme toe-out geometry causes a high amount of friction and instability.
  • Improvements to the strut suspension may be considered by adding stiffer bushings to further improve compliance.




The contents of this report are explicit properties of Japan Wind Tunnel Testing. Information may not be shared with other organizations or third parties without prior consent. Disclaimer: Japan Wind Tunnel Testing is not liable for any physical or financial damages sustained by usage of any data contained within this document.Such usage is soley the responsibility of customer.


2023 Japan Wind Tunnel Testing Inc.